The Man of the Match does not always come from the winning team. Bradford
Northern's Frank Whitcombe was the first Lance Todd Trophy winner from a losing
team in 1948, while the same fate also befell Hull's Tommy Harris (1960),
Hunslet's Brian Gabbitas (as a joint winner in 1965) and Bradford Bulls' Robbie
Paul (1996). In Leeds Rhinos' last two losing Final appearances in 2003 and
2005, Gary Connolly and Kevin Sinfield respectively have won the Lance Todd
Trophy.
Whitcombe is also the oldest winner while Peter Ramsden is the youngest, scoring
two tries on his 19th birthday to help Huddersfield claim the Challenge Cup in
1953.
| Season |
Winner |
Team |
Position |
|
2007 |
Paul Wellens |
St Helens (v
Catalan Dragons) |
Full back |
|
|
Leon Pryce |
St Helens (v
Catalan Dragons) |
Stand off |
|
2006 |
Sean Long |
St Helens (v Huddersfield Giants) |
Scrum half |
|
2005 |
Kevin Sinfield |
Leeds Rhinos (v
Hull FC) |
Stand off |
|
2004 |
Sean Long |
St Helens (v Wigan Warriors) |
Scrum half |
|
2003 |
Gary Connolly |
Leeds Rhinos (v
Bradford Bulls) |
Full back |
|
2002 |
Kris Radlinski |
Wigan Warriors (v
St. Helens) |
Full back |
|
2001 |
Sean Long |
St. Helens (v
Bradford Bulls) |
Scrum half |
|
2000 |
Henry Paul |
Bradford Bulls (v
Leeds Rhinos) |
Stand off |
|
1999 |
Leroy Rivett |
Leeds Rhinos (v
London Broncos) |
Winger |
|
1998 |
Mark Aston |
Sheffield Eagles
(v Wigan Warriors) |
Scrum half |
|
1997 |
Tommy Martyn |
St. Helens (v
Bradford Bulls) |
Stand off |
|
1996 |
Robbie Paul |
Bradford Bulls (v
St. Helens) |
Scrum half |
|
1995 |
Jason Robinson |
Wigan (v Leeds) |
Winger |
|
1994 |
Martin Offiah |
Wigan (v Leeds) |
Winger |
|
1993 |
Dean Bell |
Wigan (v Widnes) |
Loose forward |
|
1992 |
Martin Offiah |
Wigan (v
Castleford) |
Winger |
|
1991 |
Denis Betts |
Wigan (v St.
Helens) |
Second row |
|
1990 |
Andy Gregory |
Wigan (v
Warrington) |
Scrum half |
|
1989 |
Ellery Hanley |
Wigan (v St.
Helens) |
Loose forward |
|
1988 |
Andy Gregory |
Wigan (v Halifax) |
Scrum half |
|
1987 |
Graham Eadie |
Halifax (v St.
Helens) |
Full back |
|
1986 |
Bob Beardmore |
Castleford (v Hull
Kingston Rovers) |
Scrum half |
|
1985 |
Brett Kenny |
Wigan (v Hull) |
Stand off |
|
1984 |
Joe Lydon |
Widnes (v Wigan) |
Centre |
|
1983 |
David Hobbs |
Featherstone
Rovers (v Hull) |
Second row |
|
1982 |
Eddie Cunningham |
Widnes (v Hull) |
Centre |
|
1981 |
Mick Burke |
Widnes (v Hull
Kingston Rovers) |
Full back |
|
1980 |
Brian Lockwood |
Hull Kingston
Rovers (v Hull) |
Prop |
|
1979 |
David Topliss |
Wakefield Trinity
(v Widnes) |
Stand off |
|
1978 |
George Nicholls |
St. Helens (v
Leeds) |
Second row |
|
1977 |
Steve Pitchford |
Leeds (v Widnes) |
Prop |
|
1976 |
Geoff Pimblett |
St. Helens (v
Widnes) |
Full back |
|
1975 |
Ray Dutton |
Widnes (v
Warrington) |
Full back |
|
1974 |
Derek Whitehead |
Warrington (v
Featherstone Rovers) |
Full back |
|
1973 |
Steve Nash |
Featherstone
Rovers (v Bradford Northern) |
Scrum half |
|
1972 |
Kel Coslett |
St. Helens (v
Leeds) |
Loose forward |
|
1971 |
Alex Murphy |
Leigh (v Leeds) |
Scrum half |
|
1970 |
Bill Kirkbride |
Castleford (v
Wigan) |
Second row |
|
1969 |
Malcolm Reilly |
Castleford (v
Salford) |
Loose forward |
|
1968 |
Don Fox |
Wakefield Trinity
(v Leeds) |
Prop |
|
1967 |
Carl Dooler |
Featherstone
Rovers (v Barrow) |
Scrum half |
|
1966 |
Len Killeen |
St. Helens (v
Wigan) |
Winger |
|
1965 |
Ray Ashby |
Wigan |
Full back |
|
|
Brian Gabbitas |
Hunslet |
Stand off |
|
1964 |
Frank Collier |
Widnes (v Hull
Kingston Rovers) |
Prop |
|
1963 |
Harold Poynton |
Wakefield Trinity
(v Wigan) |
Stand off |
|
1962 |
Neil Fox |
Wakefield Trinity
(v Huddersfield) |
Centre |
|
1961 |
Dick Huddart |
St. Helens (v
Wigan) |
Second row |
|
1960 |
Tommy Harris |
Hull (v Wakefield
Trinity) |
Hooker |
|
1959 |
Brian McTigue |
Wigan (v Hull) |
Second row |
|
1958 |
Rees Thomas |
Wigan (v
Workington Town) |
Scrum half |
|
1957 |
Jeff Stevenson |
Leeds (v Barrow) |
Scrum half |
|
1956 |
Alan Prescott |
St. Helens (v
Halifax) |
Prop |
|
1955 |
Jack Grundy |
Barrow (v
Workington Town) |
Second row |
|
1954 |
Gerry Helme |
Warrington (v
Halifax) |
Scrum half |
|
1953 |
Peter Ramsden |
Huddersfield (v
St. Helens) |
Stand off |
|
1952 |
Billy Ivison |
Workington Town (v
Featherstone Rovers) |
Loose forward |
|
1951 |
Cec Mountford |
Wigan (v Barrow) |
Stand off |
|
1950 |
Gerry Helme |
Warrington (v
Widnes) |
Scrum half |
|
1949 |
Ernest Ward |
Bradford Northern
(v Halifax) |
Centre |
|
1948 |
Frank Whitcombe |
Bradford Northern
(v Wigan) |
Prop |
|
1947 |
Willie Davies |
Bradford Northern
(v Leeds) |
Stand off |
|
1946 |
Billy Stott |
Wakefield Trinity
(v Wigan) |
Centre |